Many “best rowing machine” pages claim they have tested dozens of machines. I doubt that you learn much from 20 minutes on 90 rowers. What matters is whether you still enjoy the machine after six months.
What I do
- I use each machine for weeks to months in a real family home, not in a gym.
- I compare the resistance types directly against each other (water, air, magnetic, dynamic), sometimes three machines at the same time.
- I record my own data: stroke rate, pace, power curve, heart rate (chest strap and wearables) and the connection to apps (ErgData, EXR, Kinomap, SmartRow, Zwift).
- I check noise, footprint, assembly, build quality and repairs.
Criteria
| Criterion | What I check |
|---|---|
| Rowing feel | Drag curve, smoothness, dynamic or static |
| Data and apps | Bluetooth/ANT+, open standards, accuracy compared with power meters |
| Noise | Measured in dB, plus feedback from the household |
| Space | Dimensions, storage, upright storage |
| Durability | Months of use, defects, spare parts, warranty |
| Price | Purchase price and running costs, not the list price |
How the machines reach me
Every test states whether I bought the machine myself, borrowed it or received it free of charge. Affiliate links are marked. Neither influences the rating. A bad result gets published.
Corrections and updates
Every test shows its publication and update dates and a short change log. Found a mistake? Write to me, I will correct it and note the change. More in the Editorial Policy and on the About page.